
Continuing the discussion.
This is another common assumption.
A company may say:
“All contracts are signed by our Ukrainian company. Therefore, there is no PE.”
Not necessarily.
The place where a contract is formally signed is only one possible factor.
It may be more important to consider:
PE is therefore largely a question of substance and actual activities, not paperwork alone.
Remote work has made PE analysis even more interesting.
An employee may live in one country, work for a company incorporated in another and have no formal office.
Does that automatically create a PE?
No.
But the analysis may need to consider:
Particular attention should be paid to remote employees performing key business functions.
No.
And this is important.
Simply having customers in a country does not automatically create a PE.
A company may have hundreds of customers in a jurisdiction while:
The analysis would look very different in that case.
So it is not useful to assess PE by saying:
“We have customers there = we have a PE.”
That is far too simplistic.
Establishing a subsidiary should not be viewed as an automatic way to “solve” the PE issue either.
A subsidiary is a separate legal entity.
But questions may still arise regarding how the parent and subsidiary operate together.
For example:
This is where PE analysis can overlap with transfer pricing and broader tax structuring.
The consequences depend on the specific jurisdiction.
Potentially, the company may have to:
And the problem may not be limited to the future.
Tax authorities may question previous periods if they believe a PE existed earlier.
That is why the structure should ideally be assessed before the business scales locally, rather than after the tax authority raises the issue.
Start by mapping the company's actual activities.
Who will work in the country?
What exactly will they do?
Who negotiates and who concludes them?
Is there an office, coworking space or another fixed place of business?
Are there agents or local partners?
Who are they and how are sales conducted?
Where are key commercial decisions actually made?
Only then should the company assess the applicable domestic rules and tax treaties.
One of the biggest mistakes is treating PE as something for the tax adviser to review after the business structure has already been built.
In reality, PE can be the result of ordinary business decisions.
For example:
“Let's hire a local sales manager.”
“Let's open a small office.”
“Let's give our local partner more authority.”
“Let's move some management functions to the new market.”
From a business perspective, these are operational decisions.
From a tax perspective, they may have very different consequences.
That is why a PE assessment should happen as part of market-entry planning, not after the local presence already exists.
Permanent Establishment is a good example of why international expansion cannot be reduced to the question:
“Where is our company incorporated?”
The more important question is:
Where and how does the business actually operate?
Local offices, employees, agents, negotiations, sales and management functions may all be relevant to determining taxable presence.
At the same time:
customers in a country ≠ automatically a PE;
a local employee ≠ automatically a PE;
no local company ≠ no PE.
Each situation needs to be assessed based on the applicable domestic law and tax treaty.
For an IT business, the best time to assess PE is before the local presence becomes a fact.
Planning to hire employees, open an office or work through local partners in another country?
Assess your structure before launch to determine whether your operating model could create a Permanent Establishment and additional tax obligations.
Request a Permanent Establishment assessment →
Subscribe to our channels on social networks:
Contact us: business@avitar.legal
Violetta Loseva
,